Pursuing excellence, customer-centricity and continuous improvement are obsolete. These conventional approaches are obsolete because they are ineffective in creating memorable customer experiences, differentiating your brand, and building your core competences.
What is their common problem? They take customers’ pain incorrectly: they avoid pain, choose the wrong pain and improve pain.
Pursuing excellence gets IN THE WAY
Will your customers be satisfied if you eliminate all their dissatisfaction? The answer is NO.
You are sitting at your desk reviewing the latest customer feedback report. Looking at the customer dissatisfaction issues raised in the report, you cannot help but frown: queuing time is too long, background music too loud, payment choices too limited… you are on edge, about to pick up the phone to call every department head and demand a revolutionary enhancement to the customer experience. But, wait just a minute; will eliminating all the customers’ dissatisfaction really keep your customers satisfied?
Figure 1 Pursuing Excellence: Avoid Pain with Insignificant Pleasure
Figure 2 Resource Revolution: Allow Pain for Significant Pleasure
Nobel-prize winning psychologist Daniel Kahneman suggested that human beings only remember two moments of any experience – the peak and the end. Figure 1 shows a grey emotion curve representing the conventional approach to customer experience management. It tries to make every moment ‘good’ from the beginning until the end of an experience. It attempts to raise the entire grey line higher and higher to achieve the highest level of industry standards. The problem of pursuing excellence is it takes lots of resource; you dilute your limited resources trying to improve too many things. This approach generates a flattened emotion curve with an insignificant peak and end. You are simply wasting your company’s resources because the experience is not remembered by your customers. When you disallow pain, you minimise pleasure.
Figure 2 illustrates a resource revolution. It takes a paradigm shift to allocate resources differently, as represented by the black curve, to allow pain and focus on the critical few moments – peak and end. This approach creates a memorable experience with significant pleasure peaks, while spending fewer resources. Resource revolution delivers more with less.
A European bank used the resource revolution in its retail operations. They allowed customers to wait in line longer and this experience generated severe pain. They saved resources, yet still ensured that each customer received high attention levels, personalised treatment and a tailored solution from their staff. The resource revolution produced rewards. Both overall customer satisfaction and the conversion rate – the percentage of customers took the next consulting appointment for investment products – improved.
Without pain, there can be no resource revolution. The resource revolution starts by allowing for pain to create significant pleasure. It requires a paradigm shift from “avoid pain” to “allow pain.” That is why pursuing excellence gets in the way – because it avoids pain.
Customer-centricity is IN THE WAY
Figure 3 Customer Centricity: Bad Pleasure & Unnecessary Pain
Figure 4 Branded Experience: Branded Pleasure & Good Pain
Should you address the most critical needs of target customers?
The answer is NO.
It has been three years since you took charge of customer centricity. For the first two years, you tried to “wow” every customer and address every pain and complains. Yet you don’t have unlimited resources to do this – what a disaster! Learning from your past mistakes, you stop trying to satisfying ‘all’ needs of ‘all’ customers. Instead, you focus your limited resources on satisfying only the ‘most critical’ needs of ‘target’ customers. This is the right way to go, isn’t it?
Figure 3 shows the logical choice for targeting customer satisfaction and pleasure in customer-centric companies – the upper two quadrants indicate the customer needs ranked highly important by customers. However, if you address all or most of the important needs of customers, you end up with too many target pleasure peaks. You dilute your resources across too many points and your peaks become insignificant – the experience will not be remembered. On the other hand, the usual choice for targeting pain – the lower two quadrants – are those needs that are not important to customers. Where customers don’t care, you can save resources. However, since these needs are not important to your customers, it is unlikely that you and your competitors have put many resources toward meeting them. You won’t save much money by making customers suffer. These are Unnecessary Pains.
Good pain is located in the upper left quadrant as shown in figure 4. Since it is important to customers, you and competitors are likely spending huge sums trying to satisfy these customer needs. By not trying to satisfy them – by allowing pain – imagine the tremendous resources that you save compared to your competitors. If you mistakenly make the Good Pain (the upper left quadrant) your target pleasure, you are doing charity work – you make customers happy but they don’t relate this to your brand. You are eating up resources to create an unnecessary pleasure peak. It is a Bad Pleasure. Instead, you should focus all your resources on the upper right quadrant, the common denominator between customer and brand, what is important both to customers and your brand – branded pleasure.
The branded pleasures of the IKEA in-store experience are product quality, price, display setting, product trial and the cafeteria. IKEA’s good pains are the car park, staff service, picking up stock, searching stock, check-out, delivery and installation; these pains are important to customers, but not to the IKEA brand. Think of the wait time and premium prices of Starbucks, the no meals, no movies, no upgrades and no reserved seats at Southwest Airlines, and Apple products incompatibility with other systems, all these pains are important to customers. By identifying their Good Pains, resources can be channelled to branded pleasures. That is why IKEA, Starbucks, Southwest, Apple and other great brands are able to deliver a highly memorable and branded experience.
Allowing Pain is not enough. To ensure that the Resource Revolution is on the right track and to create a differentiated experience, you have to choose the right pleasures and the right pains. Customer Centricity is in the way – because it focuses on the wrong pleasures and wrong pains.
Continuous improvement is IN THE WAY
Can continuously improving the customer experience build your core competences? The answer is NO.
Your CEO attended a conference last month and he was inspired: the next big thing is customer experience. His recent headaches have included regulatory changes that opened the market to competition, previous ‘hero’ products that are no longer among consumers’ favorites, and strong pressure to lower prices that eat into already slim margins. So, this inspiration comes at the right time. He quickly sets up a steering committee. Customer experience has to be improved continuously to become the company’s new core competence. Is your CEO driving your company toward a prosperous future?
Figure 5 Continuous Improvement: Improve Pain to Reduce Pleasure vs. Creative Aggravation: Aggravate Pain to Maximise Pleasure
In figure 5, on the left, it illustrates a typical Continuous Improvement scenario. It is tempting to keep improving the customer experience, especially for things that customers feel are important or painful or both. But, if you improve anything other than your Branded Pleasures, you dilute your resources and Continuous Improvement becomes destructive improvement. For every unit you spend on improving a pain point, you have one unit less to spend on your target pleasures. In a highly competitive market, you will end up lowering your pleasure peaks, weakening your comparative advantages, and turning your Blue Ocean red.
In figure 5, on the right, it shows why creative aggravation is preferred. Instead of improving pain points, you aggravate them. When you aggravate pain points to the greatest extent, you save an unprecedented amount of resources you can then use to maximise pleasures. Visually, you see a large pleasure pain gap (PPG).
Based on empirical data collected globally from 8,500 customers, Starbucks, IKEA and Louis Vuitton each have a large Pleasure Pain Gap (PPG). Based on 4,500 valid survey responses, China Merchants Bank (CMB) outperformed all 15 credit card issuing banks on all metrics, yet had the largest PPG among all major rivals.6 Based on the feedbacks of 757 IT managers, IBM has the most favorable B2B purchase experience as well as the largest PPG among 14 IT solution vendors. All these industry leaders understand Creative Aggravation.
To maximise the effectiveness of the resource revolution, you need to aggravate pains to maximise customer’s pleasures, strengthen your comparative advantages, and build your core competences. That is why Continuous Improvement is in the way – it improves the customer experience at pain points.
Embrace and unlock the power of pain
The common goal of every organisation is to earn customers’ loyalty. When customers can’t remember you, they cannot be loyal to you. The entry ticket to loyalty is creating a memorable customer experience. To stand out in the more and more homogenised world, you have to differentiate your brand. To stay ahead of the competition, you must build your core competences. Simply put, customers stay loyal to you because you make them feel good and you are different and better than your competitors.
Pursuing excellence drives ‘disremembered’ experiences by trying to perform average to good in all aspects of the customer experience. Being customer-centric makes you no different than your competitors – with everyone trying to satisfy most of the customers’ critical needs. Diluting your resources by attempting continuous improvement weakens your comparative advantage and makes you susceptible to imitation by your competitors. These conventional approaches are not the solutions to your problems; they are the problems.
Using the resource revolution to allow pain and focus resources on significant pleasure, you create memorable customer experiences. By identifying your own branded pleasure and good pain to deliver a branded experience, you differentiate your brand. By adopting creative aggravation to increase pain and free resources to generate unprecedented pleasures that are difficult for competitors to match, you turn your comparative advantages into sustainable strength and builds your core competences. These uncommon approaches are the solutions.
Figure 6 The Opposite Take on Pain: Conventional vs Uncommon Approaches
The uncommon approaches are not only the solution to creating memorable customer experiences, differentiating your brand and building your core competences, they are a more effective solution than the conventional approaches because they use fewer resources. By introducing a revolutionary perspective on pain – allow pain, choose the right pain and aggravate pain – they deliver more with less. It maximises the effectiveness of resource productivity to enable every company to put their limited resource to their best use.
The uncommon approaches are unusual but natural. They are unusual because they turn upside down how most business people perceive pain: from bad and destructive to good and creative. They are natural because they do not go to unrealistic and unsustainable extremes: only pleasure, only customer and only progress, extremes that don’t work and can’t last. They restore a realistic and sustainable balance between pleasure and pain, customer and brand, and progress and regress. Natural approaches work and last. Simply put, these uncommon approaches are effective because they embrace and unlock the power of pain.
Pain Is Good.
About Sampson Lee
I invented the PIG Strategy which was first licensed in the Netherlands and Belgium, and run the World's 1st CX Certification workshop for 60 times in 19 international cities - Amsterdam, Barcelona, Brussels, Copenhagen, Frankfurt, Milan, London, Paris, Istanbul, Dubai, Johannesburg, Shanghai, Bangkok, Hong Kong, Singapore, Sydney, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Toronto - with participants from 68 countries across six continents.
Our next CX workshop will be held in Frankfurt on October 22-23. Visit Global CEM to know more.
My book PIG Strategy is exclusively available at Global CEM.